One of the most disturbing things we learned while on vacation in Key West was the story about the trouble that the Hemingway cats are in, where they may have to be removed or caged at the Hemingway Home.
We have been to the Key West several times the past year, and each visit we spend at least two days at the home, for in our opinion, is the best attraction on the island. We recently spent a week on our annual Christmas vacation, and of that week, we spent two days at the Hemingway Home, and enjoyed it greatly.
We enjoyed spending our time at the home on each visit, and more importantly, spending the time with the Hemingway cats that roam the grounds. In all honesty, it's the cats that make the visit so enjoyable, and without them, it just won't be the same. All of the cats are very well taken care of, and look to be very happy, healthy and carefree despite the claims brought against them.
Here is a reprint from the Key West Citizen about the case brought against the Hemingway Home:
----------
Museum's Suit To Classify Cats Dismissed
KEY WEST - The 50 or so six-toed cats that wander lazily through the grounds of the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum are oblivious to the legal wranglings surrounding them, or to the complaint filed by a former museum volunteer that would have them caged or removed from the property.
On Monday, a federal judge dismissed the museum's lawsuit asking the court to declare whether the museum cats are a regulated entity, and are therefore subject to the Animal Welfare Act, which would require them to be caged.
"The act only applies to animals in commerce," said Cara Higgins, an attorney representing the museum. "These cats are not being sold or distributed, they live at the museum and they die at the museum. Some of them are 19 years old. This comes from one disgruntled former volunteer who was asked not to return, and who has cost the Hemingway Home and Museum tens of thousands of dollars."
Debra Schultz, former vice president of the local Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals and a former volunteer at the Hemingway House, filed a complaint with the U.S. Department of Agriculture in 2003, claiming the museum was violating the Animal Welfare Act, which regulates animals in commerce, Higgins said.
The USDA, after sending investigators to see the cats, subsequently filed a complaint against the museum that has spawned a legal dispute as to whether the cats fall under the federal act intended to protect animals.
"The judge did not rule that what the USDA is doing is correct," said Higgins, an attorney with Horan & Wallace, the Key West firm representing the museum. "We haven't even gotten to that issue yet. The judge just said that we are not allowed to sue the federal government. We weren't suing for money or damages, we just wanted an opinion about whether these cats are regulated."
Higgins also pointed out that Schultz was asked not to return to the museum because she was taking it upon herself to spay and neuter cats on the property.
"And she then took it upon herself to contact the federal government to come in and regulate the Hemingway House," Higgins said. "This is becoming more and more ridiculous. They're saying they're not going to be happy until the cats are caged or gone. These are local animals and the local government should regulate them, not the federal government."
Schultz could not be immediately reached for comment late Tuesday.
Attorneys for the museum have 30 days to file an appeal against the Monday ruling, but they still have to contend with the administrative complaint filed by the USDA, which will be heard by an administrative law judge.
In the meantime, Michael Morawski, one of the museum owners, said they are considering their options and the museum remains open for tours. The cats are free to move about the property — for now.
----------
This is a tragedy, and we hope that the cats will forever be associated with the home as Ernest Hemingway wanted. You can help by signing an online petition to let your voice be heard.
Click here to sign the petition, or send an email of your support directly to the Hemingway Home at
info@hemingwayhome.com, and thanks for your support. The kitties also thank you.